Paris Believes in Tears (and Love and Real Estate)
Isabelle Carre as Galle and Lambert Wilson as Dan in the 2006 film "Private Fears in Public Places" directed by Alain Resnais.
Things happen in
Alain ResnaisPrivate Fears in Public Places, much as they do in life. There is a
breakup, a brief encounter, an awkward rejection. There are hot tears
and heavy sighs. But because this is an Alain Resnais film, things
happen with elegant camera moves and syncopated editing, and they
happen to characters in near-geometric alignment: six heavenly bodies
as seen through a mighty telescope.
Pierre Arditi as Lionel in "Private Fears in Public Places."
The six include the
quarrelsome lovers, Nicole and Dan (Laura Morante and Lambert Wilson);
the real estate broker, Thierry (Andr Dussollier), whos trying to
find them a new apartment in the tough Parisian market; and the
sad-sack bartender, Lionel (Pierre Arditi), who faithfully tops off
Dans drinks. Thierry has an assistant, Charlotte (Sabine Azma), with
whom he appears infatuated, and a much-younger sister, Galle (Isabelle
Carr), who sits in cafes with a red flower pinned to her lapel,
waiting for the next SWM to pull up a chair. For her part, Charlotte
spends evenings caring for Lionels ailing, verbally abusive, unnamed
father. Here, death bangs at the door as noisily as desire.
Its
all rather complicated, kind of like life, though mostly like a stage
play. Private Fears in Public Places was written by Jean-Michel Ribes
and is based on the play of the same title by Alan Ayckbourn, who wrote
a cycle of plays that Mr. Resnais turned into the 1993 films Smoking
and No Smoking. Once again there are various characters in various
formations, conspicuously artificial sets and a suffusion of feeling,
though this time the sentiment feels heavy rather than playful.
Everyone except Galle, who looks about 35, seems firmly in middle age
or on its far side. (Mr. Resnaiss tendency to soften the focus
whenever he films his older actresses in close-up only underscores the
obvious and not with the kindness he perhaps intends.)
There is
no plot to speak of, just scenes organized around emotional encounters
and rituals. There are appointments, misunderstandings and romantic
lulls, along with some wince-worthy bump-and-grind videos. The lovers
quarrel, the broker shows his apartments and the bartender whips up
drinks and advice. There are tears, yes, but no hysterics. The mood is
polite, discreet, hushed, resolutely adult, even when the characters
fall down drunk. Mr. Resnaiss narrative techniques are similarly
refined. The edits are as smooth as the fluid camerawork, and many
scenes connect through dissolves overlaid with the image of the
ceaselessly falling snow. It doesnt snow often in Paris, but it snows
throughout Private Fears in Public Places, adding to the overall air
of gentle, twinkling unreality.
At several points in the film
Mr. Resnais places the camera directly above his sets and points down,
so we (and he) can watch the actors move about as if we were perched on
a catwalk. As with the manufactured sets and all the overtly staged
exits and entrances, this elevated point of view evokes the theater
while remaining steadfastly cinematic. Seen from above, these stagy
rooms also look like a warren, an image that brings to mind Mr.
Resnaiss Mon Oncle Amrique (1980). In that film characters sprout
the heads of rats, twitchy whiskers and all, and one fleetingly
transforms into an actual rat running in a mazelike home, a crude
metamorphosis that betrays a cynical, ungenerous view of the human
condition.
Private Fears in Public Place hasnt a trace of
cynicism. Its characters are not lab rats or types; they are people,
somewhat blurred around the edges but nonetheless alive. They work and
frolic, laugh and weep, alone and with others. All are playing
self-conscious roles son, colleague, sibling and lover that at once
define and restrict them. Despite the obvious personal and social
perks, the private love and the public profile, playing the same role
for too long can, the film suggests, take a toll. That much at least
seems true from the creased, crumpled face of Lionel, who for too many
years has performed the part of the dutiful son, faithfully caring for
the invalid father who has become as much his warden as his ward.
In
the early 1960s Mr. Resnaiss Last Year at Marienba inspired
head-scratching among critics and audiences, attracting the kind of
attention in the press now usually reserved for celebrity scandals and
box-office receipts. These days, difficult films it seems important
to add that difficult is not a pejorative rarely elicit anything but
yawns and condescension. Private Fears in Public Places is far from
difficult and that, it is also worth noting, is not a criticism. The
film is accessible, pleasant, dreamy, a touch goofy and melancholic.
Its modernist gestures are little more than stylistic tics, but there is
an image of snow falling on two clasped hands that is almost rapturous.
The role of the artist remains, for Mr. Resnais, the role of a
lifetime.
PRIVATE FEARS IN PUBLIC PLACES
Directed by
Alain Resnais;
written (in French, with English subtitles) by Jean-Michel Ribes, based
on the play by Alan Ayckbourn; director of photography, Eric Gautier;
edited by Herv de Luze; music by Mark Snow; production designers,
Jacques Saulnier, Jean-Michel Ducourty and Solange Zeitoun; produced by
Bruno Psery; released by IFC First Take. Running time: 120 minutes.
WITH: Sabine Azma (Charlotte),
Isabelle Carr (Galle), Laura Morante (Nicole), Pierre Arditi
(Lionel), Andr Dussollier (Thierry), Claude Rich (Arthur) and Lambert
Wilson (Dan).