Home Page

Saddam Trial Question and Answer - Trial update

Question and Answer Saddam Trial
 
Saddam Hussein is on trial in Iraq facing charges that include murder and torture.

How is Saddam Hussein being tried?

The former Iraqi leader is being tried along with others by Iraq's Special Tribunal (IST). The trial is being held inside Baghdad's fortress-like Green Zone in a heavily guarded courtroom.

Baghdad scene before fall of Saddam Hussein's regime
Saddam is facing Iraqi justice after 35 years of brutal rule
A panel of five judges is hearing the trial, which is being televised.

The court follows Iraqi civil law, based on the French and Egyptian models, where the judge is the chief investigator and there is no jury.

Although grounded in international law, the trial will deviate from past war crimes or crimes against humanity tribunals on some key points. Unlike most other such tribunals, Saddam Hussein could face the death penalty and will be tried by his own countrymen.

The defendants have heard the charges against them in person. Saddam Hussein's chief defence strategist is Abdel Haq Alani, an Iraqi lawyer based in Britain. It has been reported that an unspecified number of international lawyers could soon join the defence team.

The former Iraqi leader will have the right to call witnesses. If convicted, he will have the right to appeal the sentence. The appeal will be held before a nine-judge tribunal.

What has he been charged with?

To begin with Saddam Hussein was charged - along with seven others - with the killing of more than 140 men in the mostly Shia town of Dujail after a failed assassination attempt against him.

The following is a description of the case taken from IST documents:

"In July 1982, a small group of villagers attacked Saddam Hussein's convoy as it travelled through the town, located about 60 kilometres north of Baghdad. As a result, several state security forces of Saddam's regime composed of units from the Iraqi Army, Iraqi Intelligence Service and the Baath Party descended upon the Dujail. In the following few days, hundreds of people were arrested, some were executed and others including women, men and children were wrongly arrested and held at Sumawa desert in Lia location for four years. In addition, the fruit groves of the families of those arrested were destroyed."

On 4 April 2005, the tribunal announced fresh criminal charges against Saddam Hussein and six others for alleged genocide and crimes against humanity in a campaign against the Kurds dating back to the late 1980s.

The Anfal campaign resulted in the death and displacement of tens of thousands of Iraqi Kurds who were subject to repressive decrees and military operations forcing them out of "prohibited areas" in northern Iraq.

 

Who else is being tried?

Seven others are being tried alongside Saddam Hussein for the Dujail charges. These include two members of the former leader's inner circle and five lesser officials:

 

  • Barzan Ibrahim al-Tikriti: Saddam's half-brother and former head of the intelligence service. He is believed to have tortured and murdered thousands of opponents of the regime. He was captured on 16 April 2003.

     

  • Taha Yassin Ramadan: The former vice-president was captured on 18 August 2003 in Mosul. He is suspected of involvement in some of the most lethal operations conducted by Saddam's regime, including Iraq's invasion and occupation of Kuwait in 1990, the repression of Shia Muslims in 1991 and the gassing of Kurds in Halabja in 1988.

     

  • Awad Hamad al-Bandar: Former chief judge of the Revolutionary Court.

     

  • Abdullah Kadhem Ruaid, Mizher Abdullah Rawed, Ali Daeem Ali and Mohammed Azawi Ali: All former Baath party officials with responsibility for the Dujail area.

     

There are six other defendants in the Anfal changes in addition to Saddam Hussein:
  • Saddam's cousin, Ali Hassan Majid, popularly known Chemical Ali, the alleged architect of the anti-Kurdish campaign and mastermind of the 1988 Halabja attack, when thousands of civilian Kurds died in a chemical and nerve agent attack.

     

  • Former Defence Minister Sultan Hashim Ahmed, former intelligence chief Saber Abdul Aziz, former Republican Guard commander Hussein Rashid al-Tirkiti, a former Nineveh governor Taher Muhammad al-Ani and former military commander Farhan al-Jibouri.

How is Saddam fighting the case?

Saddam Hussein's lawyers have question the legitimacy of the court that was set up in 2003 under the US occupation.

Speaking to the BBC in the run-up to the trial, lawyer Abdel Haq Alani said that the tribunal was: "drafted by an occupying power."

"It has no right under international law to change the legal system of an occupied land," he said.

Mr Alani also told the BBC that in the Dujail case, the defence will argue that those killed in the village had been found guilty under Iraq's laws and Saddam Hussein's only role was to sign their death warrants.

 
Are there other concerns about the tribunal?

International human rights groups have expressed various concerns with the court and with the application of the death penalty.

The US-based Human Rights Watch questions whether the court is able to provide a fair trial. For example, guilt does not have to be proven "beyond a reasonable doubt" but instead the tribunal has to be "satisfied" of guilt. The former is the standard for other international courts.

They have also questioned the legitimacy of the Tribunal as it was established during occupation, and expressed their concern about the lack of consultation prior to drafting the statute that established the tribunal.

Could other charges be brought?

Saddam Hussein and his associates may be charged with other crimes at a later date.

The court is believed to be preparing cases that include the suppression of the 1991 Shia and Kurdish uprisings; the launching of the 1980-1988 Iran-Iraq war; and the 1990 invasion of Kuwait.

The attack on Halabja was simultaneous with, but not technically part of, the Anfal campaign and is expected to be dealt with in separate charges.

Correspondents say it is not clear whether Saddam Hussein or his co-defendants would face execution if found guilty in the Dujail case before the Anfal trial and others conclude.

15-5-2006
BAGHDAD (Reuters) - Saddam Hussein returned to court on Monday and defense witnesses were expected to testify as his trial resumed on charges of crimes against humanity in the killing of 148 Shi'ites in the 1980s, a Reuters reporter said.

The trial in the Baghdad started in October.

The 148 Shi'ite men and youths were killed after an attempt on Saddam's life in 1982 in the town of Dujail, north of Baghdad.

Saddam's seven co-accused, including his half-brother Barzan al-Tikriti, were not present in the court as the proceedings started.

 

 

The court, presided by Judge Raouf Abdel Rahman, read the charges against Saddam.

If found guilty, Saddam, 69, faces a death sentence

 
 
Iraq Body Count: War dead figures
 
The campaign group Iraq Body Count has been recording the number of civilians reported to have been killed during the Iraq war and subsequent military presence.
 
On 1 April 2006 it put the total number of civilian dead at 31,821 to 35,950 and the number of police dead at 1,950.
 

The issue of counting the number of Iraqis killed since the US-led invasion is highly controversial and the figure is disputed.

The US and UK military authorities do not record the number of civilians killed by their forces. The security situation and administrative chaos also make counting extremely difficult.
 

Figures shown include the period up to 1 April 2006
Figures are an average of the IBC minimum and maximum deaths Figures for coalition troops from Iraq Coalition Casualty Count

Iraq Body Count uses a survey of online news reports to produce its running tally, including a "minimum" and "maximum" figure where reports differ, or it is unclear whether a person killed was a civilian.

The figures include not only deaths caused by military action, but also those it considers a "direct result" of Iraq's breakdown in law and order.

In a statement on its website, Iraq Body Count says "civilian casualties are the most unacceptable consequence of all wars" and must be recorded and - if possible - investigated.

Because it relies on deaths reported by the media, it suggests its figures are an underestimate as "many if not most civilian casualties will go unreported".

On 12 December, US President George W Bush said about 30,000 Iraqis had been killed since the war began.

His spokesman later said the figure was not an official one and was based on "public estimates cited by media reports" - a method similar to that used by Iraq Body Count.

Nevertheless, Iraq Body Count's methods and its ability to compile accurate statistics have been questioned by critics, with some arguing that it has greatly underestimated the number of casualties.

One study, published by the Lancet medical journal in October 2004, suggested that poor planning, air strikes by coalition forces and a "climate of violence" had led to more than 100,000 extra deaths in Iraq.

The US and UK governments have both said the chaotic situation in Iraq makes it impossible to gather such information accurately.

 

 

Iraq ethnic groups

Iraq population density


www.thenewzealander.com